The Mystery Bookshelf

Helping You Select Truly Excellent Books

Archive for August, 2008

New Additions to the Bookshelf

Posted by henryct on August 25, 2008

Even as my bookshelf overflows, I simply can’t stop buying books.  I admit it; I’m an addict.  After reading four books in a row that weren’t good enough to recommend on this site, I keep searching for that special book. So here’s what I bought:

DIE A LITTLE by Megan Abbott (2005)
Nominated for the Anthony, Barry, and Edgar, I thought that I ought to check out this promising new author.  Her second novel, Queenpin, has also won critical acclaim.

Book Description:
This ingenious twist on a classic noir tale tells the story of Lora King, a schoolteacher, and her brother Bill, a junior investigator with the district attorney’s office. Lora’s comfortable, suburban life is jarringly disrupted when Bill falls in love with a mysterious young woman named Alice Steele, a Hollywood wardrobe assistant with a murky past.

Made sisters by marriage but not by choice, the bond between Lora and Alice is marred by envy and mistrust. Spurred on by inconsistencies in Alice’s personal history and possibly jealous of Alice’s hold on her brother, Lora finds herself lured into the dark alleys and mean streets of seamy Los Angeles. Assuming the role of amateur detective, she uncovers a shadowy world of drugs, prostitution, and ultimately, murder.

Lora’s fascination with Alice’s “sins” increases in direct proportion to the escalation of her own relationship with Mike Standish, a charmingly amoral press agent who appears to know more about his old friend Alice than he reveals. The deeper Lora digs to uncover Alice’s secrets, the more her own life begins to resemble Alice’s sinister past — and present.

THE COLD DISH by Craig Johnson
I’m a sucker for outdoor mysteries set in the American Midwest.  Cathy, over at Kittling: Books, recommended this book.

Book Description:
The citizens of the Cowboy State boast a long and bloody history of dispensing rough justice but the last few decades have bred peace between the white and Native American communities. So when Cody Pritchard is found dead near the Northern Cheyenne Reservation, Sheriff Walt Longmire and the general population of Absaroka County are inclined to think it’s a hunting accident. But two years earlier Cody was one four high school boys convicted of brutally raping Melissa Little Bird, a young Cheyenne girl with fetal alcohol syndrome. The boys were guilty but let off with suspended sentences. Was this a revenge killing? Sheriff Longmire intends to find out.

After twenty-four years as sheriff, Walt, along with Deputy Victoria Moretti and lifelong friend Henry Standing Bear, is embroiled in the most volatile and challenging case of his career. He might be the only thing standing between the three remaining boys and a Sharps .45-70 buffalo rifle.

THIRTEEN by Richard K. Morgan (2007)
Book Description:
Marsalis is one of a new breed. Literally. Genetically engineered by the U.S. government to embody the naked aggression and primal survival skills that centuries of civilization have erased from humankind, Thirteens were intended to be the ultimate military fighting force. The project was scuttled, however, when a fearful public branded the supersoldiers dangerous mutants, dooming the Thirteens to forced exile on Earth’s distant, desolate Mars colony. But Marsalis found a way to slip back–and into a lucrative living as a bounty hunter and hit man before a police sting landed him in prison–a fate worse than Mars, and much more dangerous.

Luckily, his “enhanced” life also seems to be a charmed one. A new chance at freedom beckons, courtesy of the government. All Marsalis has to do is use his superior skills to bring in another fugitive. But this one is no common criminal. He’s another Thirteen–one who’s already shanghaied a space shuttle, butchered its crew, and left a trail of bodies in his wake on a bloody cross-country spree. And like his pursuer, he was bred to fight to the death. Still, there’s no question Marsalis will take the job. Though it will draw him deep into violence, treachery, corruption, and painful confrontation with himself, anything is better than remaining a prisoner. The real question is: can he remain sane–and alive–long enough to succeed?

AN UNQUIET GRAVE by P.J. Parrish (2006)

Book Description:
In a remote corner of the Michigan woods, behind rusted iron gates and crumbling stone walls, lie one of the country’s most notorious sanitariums and its forgotten cemetery. The sprawling ruin is empty now, and the bulldozers have come to raze it. But as they do, a terrifying secret begins to emerge…

The body in Claudia Olsen’s grave is that of a stranger who died horribly. This much Louis Kincaid knows. But what happened to the woman who should be buried there? It’s a question no one will answer, one that leads Kincaid to the long, dark tunnels below the asylum and crimes of unimaginable depravity…

Now, in a place where the walls are stained with secrets, the air thick with the lingering history of screams, Louis Kincaid is on his darkest journey yet, matching wits with a monster whose work will not be silenced…

THE JAMES DEANS by Reed Farrel Coleman (2005)

Book Description:
It’s 1983 and Reaganomics is in full swing. But beneath the facade of junk bonds and easy money, New York remains a gritty metropolis offering Nirvana with one hand and desolation with the other. Moe Prager, ex-NYPD cop turned reluctant P.I. is too busy reeling from a family tragedy to see what’s coming. He’s about to be sucked into a case that might deliver him what he’s always wanted or plunge him into purgatory.

Two years earlier, Moira Heaton, a young intern for an up-and-coming politico, vanished without a trace. Although there is no evidence supporting her boss’s involvement, rumors and whispers have conspired to stall his once-promising career. Now, in a last- ditch effort to clear his name, state senator Steven Brightman, with the clout of a wealthy backer, enlists Moe’s help. With twists and turns galore and Moe’s inimitable voice, The James Deans is an absorbing page- turner that will add to the burgeoning reputation of one of today’s most promising writers.

Posted in Posts, Trip to the Bookstore | Tagged: , , | Leave a Comment »

REVIEW OF THE WEEK: The Patient’s Eyes

Posted by henryct on August 20, 2008

Written by the screenwriter of the BBC’s Murder Rooms (2001), this mystery chronicles Arthur Conan Doyle’s first meeting with the eccentric Dr. Joseph Bell. Providing the basis for Sherlock Holmes, Bell and his “method” are put to the test with a number of cases, but the series of events surrounding a beautiful patient of Doyle’s is the most sinister. As a fan of the short-lived television series, I bought the book as soon as I heard about it. Surprisingly, the book did not strictly follow the episodes that I had seen. Pirie’s evocative writing perfectly captures the memoirs of a troubled man recalling his dark past. The author also has a talent for creating an ominous, foreboding atmosphere. I’d recommend this mystery to avid Sherlock Holmes fans, but also to anyone who wants to read a dark, thrilling story.

Book Synopsis: While a young medical student at Edinburgh, Arthur Conan Doyle famously studied under the remarkable Dr Joseph Bell. Taking this as a starting point, David Pirie has woven a compelling thriller, which partners Bell and Doyle as pioneers in criminal investigation, exploring the strange underworld of violence and sexual hypocrisy running below the surface of the Victorian era. “The Patient’s Eyes” moves from Edinburgh and the strange circumstances surrounding Doyle’s meeting with the remarkable Joseph Bell to Southsea where he begins his first medical practice. There he is puzzled by the symptoms presented by Heather Grace, a sweet young woman whose parents have died tragically several years before. Heather has a strange eye complaint, but is also upset by visions of a phantom cyclist who vanishes as soon as he is followed. This enigma, however, is soon forgotten as Doyle finds himself embroiled in more threatening events – including the murder of a rich Spanish businessman – events that call for the intervention of the eminent Dr Bell.But despite coming to Doyle’s aid, perversely Dr Bell considers the murder of Senor Garcia a rather unimportant diversion from the far more sinister matter, which has brought him south: the matter of the patient’s eyes and the solitary cyclist…

Posted in Recommendations, Reviews | Tagged: , , , , , , , | Leave a Comment »

Understanding the Lingo

Posted by henryct on August 15, 2008

Cozy vs Hard-boiled

Within the genre, there are sub-categories that describe certain types of mysteries. Some people like hard-boiled detective stories; others love cozies.

COZIES

A cozy is the type of book that makes you want to curl up in a huge lounge chair with a steaming mug of tea or coffee. Full of clues and not with action, it is an intelligent mind game between the criminal and the detective. One of the best descriptions of a cozy comes from www.cluelass.com, in which common elements include: “a domestic setting such as a country house or quiet neighborhood; a limited roster of suspects, all part of the victim’s social circle; little or no description of violence or sex; a mildly romantic subplot; and an amateur sleuth or eccentric professional.” Except for a murder (or other crime), there is very little violence and no gory details of the crime.

Classic authors: Agatha Christie, Ngaio Marsh, and Arthur Conan Doyle
Modern authors: Nancy Atherton, Donna Andrews, Julia Spencer-Fleming, Laurie R. King, and Aaron Elkins
My favorite cozy: Old Bones by Aaron Elkins

HARD-BOILED

Almost the exact opposite of a cozy is the hard-boiled sub-genre. Originally found in “pulp” detective magazines, this popular form of crime fiction surfaced in the 1920s-1940s. Common features: “a lone-wolf private detective, cynical yet quixotic; the mean streets of the inner city; characters from both the professional criminal class and the criminally rich; and liberal additions of violent action and disassociated sex.” (www.cluelass.com) But Raymond Chandler put it best: “[Hard-boiled] characters live in a world gone wrong…and the streets are dark with something more than night.”

Classic authors: Dashiell Hammett, James M. Cain, and Raymond Chandler
Modern authors: Dennis Lehane, James Lee Burke, Lawrence Block, and Charlie Huston
My favorite hard-boiled mystery: Gone, Baby, Gone by Dennis Lehane

POLICE PROCEDURALS

In police procedurals, the protagonist is usually a member of the police force who uses the forensic rules of evidence and departmental procedures to solve the crime.

Classic authors: Ed McBain, Joseph Wambaugh, Reginald Hill, and Ruth Rendell
Modern authors: Michael Connelly, Peter Robinson, T. Jefferson Parker, and Ian Rankin
My favorite police procedural: City of Bones by Michael Connelly

HISTORICAL

In historical mysteries, the crime occurs in the past rather than in contemporary times. The mystery is usually about a period of history prior to the life of the writer who wrote it. Even though their setting would now be considered historical, classic mysteries, such as Sherlock Holmes and Poirot (which were contemporary when written), are not considered part of the historical sub-genre.

Classic authors: Ellis Peters and Elizabeth Peters
Modern authors: Charles Todd, Rhys Bowen, Lindsey Davis, David Liss, and C.J. Sansom
My favorite historical mystery: River of Darkness by Rennie Airth

I mostly read hard-boiled detectives and police procedurals.  So what sub-genre do you like the most?

Posted in Posts | Tagged: , , , , , , , | 1 Comment »

AUTHOR PROFILE: T. Jefferson Parker

Posted by henryct on August 14, 2008

T. Jefferson Parker
Credit: Marion Ettlinger

Maybe not as famous as his two west coast counterparts, Michael Connelly and Robert Crais, T. Jefferson Parker is most definitely in their league.  Born in Los Angeles, Parker has lived all of his life in Southern California. Following a bachelor’s degree in English at the University of California, he started his writing career as a report for the Newport Ensign.  After covering the police and city hall, Parker moved on to the Daily Pilot, where he won three Orange County Press Club awards.  His first book, Laguna Heat, written in his spare time, received rave reviews and was made into an HBO movie.  Since then, he’s written fourteen more books about crime in sunny Southern California.  Mostly a writer of stand-alones, Parker’s only series features the brazen Detective Merci Rayborn. All three books in the series, The Blue Hour, Red Light, and Black Water, easily became bestsellers.  However, it was his two Edgar Awards for Best Novel that really put him on the map.  He won for Silent Joe (one of my all-time favorites) and California Girl.

Another favorite of mine is The Fallen, which didn’t receive as much notoriety of Silent Joe, but is of similar quality.  I mean, who can’t resist reading about a cop with synesthesia?  (It’s a condition which allows him to recognize when suspects and witnesses are lying to him.) Parker is one of the most talented and prolific authors writing mysteries today. If you’ve never read any of his books before, you’re in for a treat.

His novels are:

Laguna Heat – 1985
Little Saigon – 1988
Pacific Beat – 1991
Summer Of Fear – 1993
The Triggerman’s Dance – 1996
Where Serpents Lie – 1998
The Blue Hour – 1999 (1st in the Merci Rayborn series)
Red Light – 2000 (2nd Merci Rayborn novel)
Silent Joe – 2001
Black Water – 2002 (3rd Merci Rayborn novel)
Cold Pursuit – 2003
California Girl – 2004
The Fallen – 2006
Storm Runners – 2007
L.A. Outlaws – 2008

Posted in Author Profiles, Recommendations | Tagged: , , , | Leave a Comment »

TWO OF MY FAVORITES: One Thriller and One Mystery

Posted by henryct on August 13, 2008

Of all the books that I’ve read in 2008, these two are my favorites. I’d never heard of these authors before, but you can bet that I’ll be first in line for their next book release. If you like your fiction hard-boiled, these should the next two books you read.

The first is Marcus Sakey’s The Blade Itself. This is Sakey’s first novel, and it’s a real winner. In a nutshell, it’s an excellent character study of an ex-con, who finally goes legit, and then his old, psychopathic partner shows up to threaten all that he’s worked for. Sakey builds the tension to an almost overwhelming level. And that’s why it’s so good, it’s so visceral you feel as if you’ve just been kicked in the gut. You will remember this book long after you finish reading it.

Book Synopsis: On the South Side of Chicago, you’re only as strong as your reputation. Danny Carter and his best friend Evan earned theirs knocking over pawnshops and liquor stores, living from score to score, never thinking of tomorrow…until, in the roar of a gun blast, everything changed. Years later, Danny has built a new life: a legitimate career, a long-term girlfriend, and a clean conscience. He’s just like anyone else. Normal. Successful. Happy. Until then he spots his old partner staring him down in a smoky barroom mirror… Now, with all he loves on the line and nowhere to turn, Danny realizes his new life hinges on a terrible choice: How far will he go to protect his future from his past?

_

The second book is Charlie Huston’s Already Dead. In the last few years, I’d heard about this relatively unknown talent, so I finally decided to pick up one of Charlie Huston’s books. After reading Already Dead, I’m a believer. This is one of my favorite hard-boiled mysteries of all time. Huston surprised me at every turn. The main character is a private detective in New York (nothing new there, right?), but he’s also a vampire. In classic noir fashion, Joe Pitt is a rogue, who doesn’t want to be associated with any of New York’s clans.  He’s hired to find a teenage runaway and daughter of one of New York’s leading human families, who likes to dress in goth (funny, right?). The world Huston creates is absolutely fascinating. I was drawn into it, and I wanted to stay. Good thing there’s a sequel.

Book Synopsis: There’s a shambler on the loose. Some fool who got himself infected with a flesh-eating bacteria is lurching around, trying to munch on folks’ brains. Joe hates shamblers, but he’s still the one who has to deal with them. That’s just the kind of life he has. Except afterlife might be better word. From the Battery to the Bronx, and from river to river, Manhattan is crawling with Vampyres. Joe is one of them, and he’s not happy about it. Yeah, he gets to be stronger and faster than you, and he’s tough as nails and hard to kill. But spending his nights trying to score a pint of blood to feed the Vyrus that’s eating at him isn’t his idea of a good time. And Joe doesn’t make it any easier on himself. Going his own way, refusing to ally with the Clans that run the undead underside of Manhattan–it ain’t easy. It’s worse once he gets mixed up with the Coalition–the city’s most powerful Clan–and finds himself searching for a poor little rich girl who’s gone missing in Alphabet City. Now the Coalition and the girl’s high-society parents are breathing down his neck, anarchist Vampyres are pushing him around, and a crazy Vampyre cult is stalking him. No time to complain, though. Got to find that girl and kill that shambler before the whip comes down . . . and before the sun comes up.

Posted in Recommendations | Tagged: , , , | 3 Comments »

REVIEW OF THE WEEK: High Crimes

Posted by henryct on August 11, 2008

High Crimes is an excellent legal thriller! If you liked the movie “A Few Good Men,” you will LOVE the courtroom intrigue of this military thriller. After being married for three years, Claire Chapman, a highly regarded legal scholar, discovers that her husband isn’t who she thought he was.  After a failed but action-packed attempt to capture him, the FBI tell her that his name isn’t even Tom Chapman, but Ron Kubick, an AWOL Special Forces commando. Kubick is AWOL and a wanted mass murder.  As he tells it, during a top-secret mission in El Salvador thirteen years ago, the commander in charge, now a high-ranking General, ordered the killing of 87 unarmed inhabitants, and he refused to take part. Since he wouldn’t go along with the slaughter, the General made him the scapegoat. When Kubick is inevitably incarcerated, Claire defends him in military court.  And yet the prosecution has strong evidence that he acted alone and sadistically enjoyed killing people. Hidden microphones, identical sworn statements, and threats against her life all point to a military conspiracy. She can’t fathom why the government is so eager to frame her husband. As the evidence mounts, it will take all of her legal expertise to save him from a death sentence. With your heart thumping out of your chest, author Joseph Finder throws curve balls and twists until you finally reach the satisfying conclusion.

I’m glad that I finally read one of Joseph Finder’s thrillers.  For years, I’ve heard he’s the very best.  Now I’m a believer.  Next time, I’ll try his popular and highly-acclaimed Paranoia.

Posted in Recommendations, Reviews | Tagged: , , | 1 Comment »

Four Recommended Historical Mysteries

Posted by henryct on August 7, 2008

To Americans, great historical mysteries tend to be set in Britain.  There’s something about the landscape that sends chills down your spine.  My favorite historical thrillers usually take place right after WWI or WWII, but I’ve also included an excellent Victorian mysteries in my list.  Since I’ve already mentioned several times how much I love C.J. Sansom’s medieval mysteries set in Tudor England, I’ll leave him out of this list.  Enjoy these haunting trips to the past:

1. River of Darkness – Rennie Airth (1999)
In rural England, in a landscape shadowed by the sorrow of World War I, the peace of a small Surrey village is shattered by a murderous attack, which leaves five butchered bodies and no motive for the killings. Sent by Scotland Yard to investigate is Inspector John Madden, a grave and good man who bears the emotional and physical scars from his own harrowing war experiences and from the tragic loss of his wife and child. The local police dismiss the slaughter as a robbery gone tragically awry, but Madden and his chief inspector detect the work of a madman. With the help of a beautiful doctor who introduces Madden to the latest developments in forensic psychology and who opens his heart again to the possibility of love, Madden sets out to identify and capture the killer–a demented former soldier with a bloody past–even as he sets his sights on his next innocent victims. As darkly stylish as the best of P. D. James, rippled with tension and resonant with historical atmosphere, River of Darkness marks the debut of a powerful new voice in suspense writing and of a compelling character whom readers will long to know better.

2. A Test of Wills – Charles Todd (1996)
The Great War has been won—but victory has its price. The year is 1919, and Ian Rutledge has returned to London to resume his position as Scotland Yard inspector, bringing nightmares and ghosts home with him from the French battlefields. Tormented and suffering from shell shock, he is immediately plunged into the affair of a popular colonel believed murdered by a decorated war hero—a case that is a personal and political minefield that could destroy Rutledge’s career and what remains of his sanity.

_

3. An Unpardonable Crime – Andrew Taylor (2004) Known as American Boy in the UK
England 1819. Two enigmatic Americans arrive in London and soon after a bank collapses. A man is found dead on a building site; another goes missing in the teeming stews of the city’s notorious Seven Dials district. A deathbed vigil ends in an act of theft, and a beautiful heiress flirts with her inferiors. A strange destiny connects each of these events to an American boy, Edgar Allan Poe, who was brought to England by his foster father and sent to the leafy village of Stoke Newington to be educated. An Unpardonable Crime is a twenty-first-century novel with a nineteenth-century voice. It is both a multilayered literary murder mystery and a love story, its setting ranging from the coal-scented fogs of late-Regency London to the stark winter landscapes of Gloucestershire. And at its center is the boy who does not really belong anywhere, an actor who never learns the significance of his part.

4. In a Dry Season – Peter Robinson (1999)
In the blistering, dry summer, the waters of Thornfield Reservior have been depleted, revealing the ruins of the small Yorkshire village that lay at its bottom, bringing with it the unidentified bones of a brutally murdered young woman. Detective Chief Inspector Banks faces a daunting challenge: he must unmask a killer who has escaped detection for half a century. Because the dark secret of Hobb’s End continue to haunt the dedicated policeman even though the town that bred then has died—and long after its former residents have been scattered to far places . . . or themselves to the grave.

Enjoy!

Posted in Recommendations | Tagged: , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment »

THE MOST AWARDED FIRST NOVELS SINCE 2000

Posted by henryct on August 7, 2008

How do you know if a new author is really good?  As I explained in another post, one of my favorite methods is to critically assess the numerous awards given throughout the year by different associations. I figure that if a book has been nominated for at least four awards, it must be a very good mystery.  Over the years, my “system” has never failed me.  Every book has been truly satisfying, and nearly every book on this list is one the best mysteries that I have ever read.

1. Open Season – C.J. Box (2001)
ANTHONY WINNER,
MACAVITY WINNER,
BARRY WINNER,
GUMSHOE WINNER,
Edgar Nominee,
LA Times Nominee

2. In the Bleak Midwinter – Julia Spencer-Fleming (2002)
ANTHONY WINNER,
MACAVITY WINNER,
BARRY WINNER,
DILYS WINNER,
AGATHA WINNER,
Gumshoe Nominee

3. Still Life – Louise Penny (2006)
ANTHONY WINNER,
BARRY WINNER,
DILYS WINNER
CREASEY NEW BLOOD DAGGER WINNER
ARTHUR ELLIS WINNER

4. A Conspiracy of Paper – David Liss (2000)
EDGAR WINNER,
MACAVITY WINNER,
BARRY WINNER,
Anthony Nominee

_

5. Monkeewrench – P.J. Tracy (2003)
ANTHONY WINNER,
BARRY WINNER,
GUMSHOE WINNER,
Dilys Nominee

_

6. The Distance – Eddie Muller (2004)
SHAMUS WINNER,
GUMSHOE WINNER,
Anthony Nominee,
Macavity Nominee,
Barry Nominee

7. King of Lies – John Hart (2007)
GUMSHOE WINNER,
Edgar Nominee,
Anthony Nominee,
Macavity Nominee,
Barry Nominee

8. Immoral – Brian Freeman (2005)
MACAVITY WINNER,
Edgar Nominee,
Anthony Nominee,
Barry Nominee,
Dagger Nominee

9. Blindsighted – Karin Slaughter (2001)
DAGGER WINNER,
Macavity Nominee,
Barry Nominee,
Gumshoe Nominee

_


The Awards:

  • The Edgar Allan Poe Award® is awarded every April by the Mystery Writers of America (MWA). Eligible novels must be published in the U.S. in English and nominated by the publisher.
  • The Anthony Award, named for mystery reviewer Anthony Boucher, is bestowed every summer at the Boucheron World Mystery Convention. Eligible books must be published in the U.S. in English and nominated by a Bouchercon registrant.
  • The Shamus Award is given by the Private Eye Writers of America (PWA). Eligible novels feature a professional private investigator (someone not employed by the government or police).
  • The Macavity Award, named for the “mystery cat” of T.S. Eliot’s Old Possum’s Book of Practical Cats, is bestowed annually at Bouchercon by Mystery Readers International (MRI).
  • The Barry Award, named for fan reviewer Barry Gardner, is bestowed annually at Bouchercon by fan-oriented Deadly Pleasures Mystery Magazine (DP).
  • The DILYS Award has been given annually since 1993 by the Independent Mystery Booksellers Association to the mystery titles of the year which the member booksellers have most enjoyed selling.
  • The Los Angeles Times Book Prize is awarded every Spring, highlighting the newspaper’s annual Festival of Books. Eight panels of three judges each provide all nominations and choose both finalists and winners.
  • The Hammett Prize is awarded annually by The North American Branch of the International Association of Crime Writers for literary excellence in the field of crime writing.
  • The Gumshoe Award is given annually by Mystery Ink magazine to recognize the best achievements in crime fiction.
  • The Agatha Award is bestowed at Malice Domestic®, an annual convention in Washington D.C. which salutes the “traditional mystery” typified by the works of Agatha Christie—no explicit sex or violence, amateur detective, confined setting, characters who know each other.

Posted in Awards, Recommendations | Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a Comment »

Haven’t read a good book in awhile?

Posted by henryct on August 6, 2008

Haven’t read a good mystery or thriller in ages?  Have trouble selecting your next book?  I have two designated areas on my bookshelf.  One is for my favorite authors, like Robert Crais, Michael Connelly, Dennis Lehane, Charlie Huston, and more.  The other shelf is for “New” authors, who I’ve never read before.  To guarantee that I have truly satisfying reading experiences, I alternate between reading a “New” author and a “Favorite” author.  This way I read books written by up-and-coming or classic authors and then I can fall back to the characters who I really love.  Sometimes a “New” author becomes a “Favorite,” which is what you really want to happen.  Try it.  I guarantee that it will broaden your knowledge of the genre and introduce you to new favorite authors.

On the same note, I alternate between sub-genres too.  For example, if I just read a police procedural, the next book might be a hard-boiled P.I. or a historical mystery.  Sometimes if I just read a mystery, I might read a thriller afterward.  This way, I never tire of reading my favorite genre.

Posted in Posts, Recommendations | Tagged: , , , , , , , | Leave a Comment »

AWARD WINNING MYSTERIES SINCE 2000

Posted by henryct on August 5, 2008

How do you choose what mystery books to read? One of my most successful methods is to critically assess the numerous awards given throughout the year by different associations. Knowing that awards can be very political, I look at the breadth of a book’s accomplishment, i.e. how many nominations did it win, rather than the number of awards it won. I figure that if a book has been nominated for at least four awards, it must be a very good mystery. Over the years, my “system” has never failed me. Every book has been truly satisfying, and nearly every book on this list is one the best mysteries that I have ever read.

THE MOST AWARDED MYSTERY NOVELS:

placeofexecution1. A Place of Execution – Val McDermid (2000)
ANTHONY WINNER,
MACAVITY WINNER,
DILYS WINNER,
LA TIMES WINNER,
Edgar Nominee
_

2. Mystic River – Dennis Lehane (2001)
ANTHONY WINNER,
MACAVITY WINNER,
BARRY WINNER,
DILYS WINNER,
Hammett Nominee
_

whatthedeadknow3. What the Dead Know – Laura Lippman (2007)
ANTHONY WINNER,
BARRY WINNER,
MACAVITY WINNER,
Dagger Nominee,
Gumshoe Nominee
_

4. The Lincoln Lawyer – Michael Connelly (2005)
MACAVITY WINNER,
SHAMUS WINNER,
Edgar Nominee,
Anthony,
Dagger Nominee,
LA Times Nominee,
Gumshoe Nominee

5. City of Bones – Michael Connelly (2002)
ANTHONY WINNER,
BARRY WINNER,
Edgar Nominee,
Macavity Nominee,
Dagger Nominee,
Gumshoe Nominee

6. Winter and Night - S.J. Rozan (2002)
EDGAR WINNER,
MACAVITY WINNER,
Shamus Nominee,
Anthony Nominee,
Barry Nominee

7. Silent Joe – T. Jefferson Parker (2001)
EDGAR WINNER,
LA TIMES WINNER,
Macavity Nominee,
Barry Nominee,
Gumshoe Nominee,
Hammett Nominee

8. California Girl - T. Jefferson Parker (2004)
EDGAR WINNER,
Anthony Nominee,
Macavity Nominee,
Gumshoe Nominee,
Hammett Nominee

9. The Guards – Ken Bruen (2003)
SHAMUS WINNER,
Edgar Nominee,
Macavity Nominee,
Barry Nominee
_

soul-patchSoul Patch – Reed Coleman (2007)
SHAMUS WINNER,
Edgar Nominee,
Barry Nominee,
Macavity Nominee(

_o_

10. The Bottoms – Joe R. Lansdale (2000)
EDGAR WINNER,
Anthony Nominee,
Macavity Nominee,
Hammett Nominee

_


The Awards:

  • The Edgar Allan Poe Award® is awarded every April by the Mystery Writers of America (MWA). Eligible novels must be published in the U.S. in English and nominated by the publisher.
  • The Anthony Award, named for mystery reviewer Anthony Boucher, is bestowed every summer at the Boucheron World Mystery Convention. Eligible books must be published in the U.S. in English and nominated by a Bouchercon registrant.
  • The Shamus Award is given by the Private Eye Writers of America (PWA). Eligible novels feature a professional private investigator (someone not employed by the government or police).
  • The Macavity Award, named for the “mystery cat” of T.S. Eliot’s Old Possum’s Book of Practical Cats, is bestowed annually at Bouchercon by Mystery Readers International (MRI).
  • The Barry Award, named for fan reviewer Barry Gardner, is bestowed annually at Bouchercon by fan-oriented Deadly Pleasures Mystery Magazine (DP).
  • The DILYS Award has been given annually since 1993 by the Independent Mystery Booksellers Association to the mystery titles of the year which the member booksellers have most enjoyed selling.
  • The Los Angeles Times Book Prize is awarded every Spring, highlighting the newspaper’s annual Festival of Books. Eight panels of three judges each provide all nominations and choose both finalists and winners.
  • The Hammett Prize is awarded annually by The North American Branch of the International Association of Crime Writers for literary excellence in the field of crime writing.
  • The Gumshoe Award is given annually by Mystery Ink magazine to recognize the best achievements in crime fiction.

Posted in Awards, Recommendations | Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment »